Study Notes – Reasoning Ability
Topic: Statement & Conclusion
(For “Bihar Police Constable” exam – Reasoning Ability section)
1. Simple Explanation
A statement is a factual claim that can be true or false.
A conclusion (or inference) is a statement derived from one or more given statements using logical rules.
In reasoning puzzles, you are given:
- A set of statements (premises).
- A conclusion that must be checked against those statements.
The task: determine whether the conclusion necessarily follows, might follow, or cannot follow from the statements.
2. Key Points
| Aspect | What to Look For | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| Logical Connectives | AND, OR, NOT, IF … THEN, ONLY IF |
They dictate how statements combine. |
| Universal vs. Existential | “All A are B” vs. “Some A are B” | Determines strength of inference. |
| Contrapositive | From If A then B, infer If not B then not A. |
Useful for deriving new conclusions. |
| Transitivity | If A → B and B → C, then A → C. |
Helps chain deductions. |
| Contradiction | If a conclusion contradicts a given statement, it is invalid. | Avoids false inferences. |
| Validity Types | Valid (must be true), Possibly Valid (could be true), Invalid (certainly false). | Determines answer choice. |
| Common Pitfalls | • Assuming universal statements imply existential ones. • Ignoring “only if” vs. “if”. • Over‑extending from a single statement. |
Leads to wrong conclusions. |
3. Worked Example
Given Statements
- All students who study hard pass the exam.
S → P(S = “studies hard”, P = “passes”) - If a student passes the exam, they get a certificate.
P → C(C = “gets certificate”) - No student who fails the exam gets a certificate.
¬P → ¬C
Conclusion to Test
“All students who get a certificate pass the exam.”
C → P
Step‑by‑Step Analysis
| Step | Reasoning | Logic |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | From 2: P → C. Take contrapositive: ¬C → ¬P. |
Inverse relation |
| 2 | From 3: ¬P → ¬C. Take contrapositive: C → P. |
This is exactly the conclusion. |
| 3 | Conclusion follows logically from statements 2 & 3. It is necessarily true. | Valid |
Result: The conclusion is Valid (must be true).
4. Quick Revision Summary
| Item | What to Remember |
|---|---|
| Identify the logical form of each statement (universal, conditional, etc.). | |
Translate statements into symbolic form (→, ∧, ∨, ¬). |
|
| Apply contraposition, transitivity, and other inference rules. | |
| Check for contradictions or gaps in the chain of reasoning. | |
| Classify the conclusion as Valid, Possibly Valid, or Invalid. | |
| Practice with many short puzzles to reinforce pattern recognition. |
Practice Tip
During the exam, first sketch the logical diagram (implication arrows) before deciding a conclusion’s validity. This visual aid prevents oversight and speeds up decision‑making.
Good luck with your preparation!