Statement & Conclusion – Reasoning Ability
Uttarakhand Police Constable
Program: Reasoning Ability – “Statement & Conclusion”
1. Simple Explanation
- Statement – A fact or piece of information given in a question (often called premise).
- Conclusion – A logical inference that follows from the statement(s).
- Goal: Decide whether the conclusion logically follows always from the statement(s).
- Answer choices
- Conclusion always follows.
- Conclusion may follow.
- Conclusion never follows.
- None of the above (used when the conclusion is unrelated).
2. Key Points
| # | Concept | How to Spot It | Common Patterns |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Logical Connectives | if…then, and, or, not, only if, unless, except |
All A are B. All B are C. → All A are C |
| 2 | Universal vs. Particular | Universal: “All/Every/No” → applies to every element. Particular: “Some/Any/At least one” | Universal → Particular → Universal (e.g., “All A are B” & “Some B are C” → “Some A are C”) |
| 3 | Syllogistic Forms | Standard 2‑premise syllogisms (e.g., Barbara, Celarent, Darii, etc.) | Learn the 19 valid syllogistic moods |
| 4 | Logical Contradiction | If a statement contradicts the conclusion, the conclusion never follows. | “All X are Y” and “No X is Y” → cannot infer any X is Y |
| 5 | Relevance | Conclusion must be directly related to the statement(s). | “All dogs are mammals” → “All mammals are animals” is relevant, “All cats are mammals” is not. |
| 6 | Exclusion of Extra Assumptions | Do not add facts not present in the statement(s). | If not stated that “John is a teacher”, you cannot conclude “John teaches”. |
3. Worked Example
Statement (S):
- “All engineers who work in the city are senior engineers.”
- “Some senior engineers in the city are also architects.”
Conclusion (C):
“All engineers who work in the city are also architects.”
Step‑by‑Step Analysis
| Step | Action | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Translate into logical form. |
- Let E = engineer, C = city, S = senior, A = architect.
- Premise 1: ∀x (E(x) ∧ City(x) → Senior(x))
- Premise 2: ∃x (Senior(x) ∧ City(x) ∧ Architect(x)) | | 2 | Check if C follows from premises. | C states: ∀x (E(x) ∧ City(x) → Architect(x)) | | 3 | Identify missing link. | Premise 1 gives Seniorness, Premise 2 gives some Senior that are Architects, but not all Senior. | | 4 | Conclusion requires universal claim about all such engineers. | Not supported because we only know some of them are architects. | | 5 | Verdict | Conclusion never follows (Option 3). |
Answer: 3. Conclusion never follows.
4. Quick Revision Summary
| Topic | What to Remember |
|---|---|
| Definition | Statement = premise, Conclusion = inference. |
| Answer choices | 1) Always, 2) May, 3) Never, 4) Irrelevant. |
| Logical Connectives | if…then, and, or, except, unless. |
| Universal vs. Particular | Universal → Particular → Universal is valid. |
| Syllogisms | 19 valid moods; practice the most common. |
| Avoid Extra Assumptions | Only use given facts. |
| Check Relevance | Conclusion must be a logical consequence of the statement(s). |
| Common Mistake | Assuming “some” implies “all” or vice‑versa. |
Tip for Exam:
- Read the statement carefully.
- Identify the logical structure (universal, particular, conditional).
- Test the conclusion against each premise.
- Mark “never” if you find any counter‑example or missing link.
- Mark “may” if you can’t prove it always but it’s not contradicted.
- Mark “always” only when the conclusion is logically forced by the premises.
Good luck with your preparation!