Syllogism – Study Notes (Himachal Pradesh PSC – Reasoning Ability)
1. Simple Explanation
A syllogism is a short logical argument that consists of two premises followed by a conclusion.
It is used to test the ability to deduce a conclusion that follows necessarily from the given statements.
Structure
| Part | Content | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Major Premise | A general statement (universal or universal negative). | All mammals are warm‑blooded. |
| Minor Premise | A specific statement that applies to a particular case. | All dogs are mammals. |
| Conclusion | The logical inference drawn from the two premises. | All dogs are warm‑blooded. |
Tip: The conclusion must be a necessary consequence of the premises. If the conclusion can be false even when both premises are true, the syllogism is invalid.
2. Key Points to Remember
| # | Concept | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Premise Types | • Universal affirmative: All A are B. • Universal negative: No A are B. • Particular affirmative: Some A are B (rare in PSC). • Particular negative: Some A are not B (rare). |
Determines the logical form. |
| 2. Syllogistic Figures | 3 figures based on the position of the middle term (the term that appears in both premises). • Figure 1: Middle term is subject in major, predicate in minor. • Figure 2: Middle term is predicate in both premises. • Figure 3: Middle term is subject in both premises. |
The figure influences validity. |
| 3. Mood (Quality of Premises) | Moods like AAA (All A are B; All B are C; → All A are C) or EAE (No A are B; All B are C; → No A are C). | Each mood has a specific validity pattern. |
| 4. Validity Rules | • Barbara (AAA‑1) is valid. • Celarent (EAE‑1) is valid. • Darii (AII‑1) is valid. • Others (e.g., Illicit major/minor) are invalid. |
Memorize the valid moods for quick checking. |
| 5. Contradictions and Negations | If a premise states No A are B, the conclusion cannot state All A are B. | Avoiding logical contradictions. |
| 6. Common Mistakes | • Assuming the conclusion can be “some” when premises are universal. • Mixing up the figure and mood. • Forgetting that the middle term must appear in both premises. |
Reduces errors in exam. |
3. Worked Example
Question
- All engineers are architects.
- Some architects are not designers.
- Therefore, some engineers are not designers.
Step‑by‑Step Analysis
| Step | Action | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Identify terms | A = Engineers, B = Architects, C = Designers | |
| 2. Determine premise types | P1: All A are B (universal affirmative). P2: Some B are not C (particular negative). |
|
| 3. Figure | Middle term B appears as predicate in P1, subject in P2 → Figure 2. | |
| 4. Check mood | P1 = A, P2 = I (particular), so mood = AI (Figure 2). | |
| 5. Validity | The only valid mood for Figure 2 with AI is I? Actually AI‑2 is "Illicit Major", invalid. | |
| 6. Conclusion | The conclusion “Some engineers are not designers” (I) would be valid only if the mood were I (AI‑2). But AI‑2 is invalid → Answer: Invalid. |
Result
The syllogism is invalid. The correct conclusion could not be drawn from the premises.
4. Quick Revision Summary
| Topic | Key Take‑Away |
|---|---|
| Structure | Major Premise + Minor Premise → Conclusion |
| Figures | 1, 2, 3 – position of middle term |
| Moods | AAA, EAE, AII, etc. – combine with figure |
| Validity | Only certain moods in each figure are valid (e.g., Barbara, Celarent, Darii). |
| Common Pitfalls | Wrong figure, wrong mood, ignoring middle term, mixing universal with particular. |
| Exam Tip | Write down the terms, classify each premise, match figure & mood, then check validity before selecting the answer. |
Final Thought
Mastering syllogisms is all about pattern recognition: terms → figure → mood → validity. Practice with varied examples, and soon you’ll spot the correct answer in seconds. Good luck with your PSC preparation!