Study Notes – Reasoning Ability
Topic: Statement & Conclusion
“Statement & Conclusion” is a common question type in reasoning tests.
The test‑taker is given a statement (or a set of statements) and a list of conclusions.
The task is to determine which conclusion(s) are necessarily true based on the statement(s).
1. Simple Explanation
- Statement – The information provided (facts, facts about people, time, etc.).
- Conclusion – A claim that might be derived from the statement.
- Rule of Derivation – A conclusion is valid only if it logically follows from the statement for all possible scenarios implied by the statement.
- Invalid Conclusion – If there is any scenario consistent with the statement where the conclusion fails, the conclusion is not valid.
2. Key Points to Remember
| # | Point | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Understand the type of statement – Is it a single fact, a set of facts, or a conditional clause? | Different strategies apply. |
| 2 | Identify all possible scenarios that satisfy the statement. | Validity depends on every scenario. |
| 3 | Check for hidden assumptions – e.g., “if A then B” does not imply “B” alone. | Avoid over‑generalization. |
| 4 | Look for logical fallacies – e.g., affirming the consequent, denying the antecedent. | Common traps. |
| 5 | Use elimination – If a conclusion contradicts the statement or a known fact, discard it. | Saves time. |
| 6 | Multiple correct conclusions – Some questions allow more than one. | Mark all that are strictly derived. |
| 7 | Remember “not necessarily” – The statement might allow but not force the conclusion. | Key to distinguishing valid from invalid. |
3. Worked Example
Statement:
“If the train departs from City A at 9 AM, it will arrive at City B at 11 AM.
If the train departs from City A at 10 AM, it will arrive at City B at 12 PM.”
Conclusions:
a) The train takes 2 hours to travel from City A to City B.
b) The train takes 3 hours to travel from City A to City B.
c) The train arrives at City B at 12 PM.
d) The train departs from City A at 10 AM.
Step‑by‑Step
-
Translate the statement into logical form.
- (P_1): ( \text{Departs at 9 AM} \Rightarrow \text{Arrives at 11 AM})
- (P_2): ( \text{Departs at 10 AM} \Rightarrow \text{Arrives at 12 PM})
-
Derive all possible scenarios.
- Scenario 1: Departs 9 AM → Arrives 11 AM (duration 2 h).
- Scenario 2: Departs 10 AM → Arrives 12 PM (duration 2 h).
- No information about other departure times.
-
Evaluate each conclusion.
| Conclusion | Check | Result |
|---|---|---|
| a) 2 hours travel | Both scenarios give 2 h. | True (necessarily) |
| b) 3 hours travel | No scenario gives 3 h. | False |
| c) Arrives at 12 PM | Only Scenario 2 arrives 12 PM; Scenario 1 does not. | False |
| d) Departs at 10 AM | Scenario 1 departs 9 AM; Scenario 2 departs 10 AM. | False |
Answer: Only conclusion (a) is valid.
4. Quick Revision Summary
- Definition: Statement = given facts; Conclusion = inference that may or may not follow.
- Validity Test: Conclusion must hold in every scenario allowed by the statement.
- Common Pitfalls:
- Assuming “if A then B” implies “B” alone.
- Confusing “may” with “must”.
- Ignoring hidden possibilities.
- Strategy:
- Write down all scenarios.
- Check each conclusion against every scenario.
- Mark only those that are true in all scenarios.
Tip: When in doubt, think of a counter‑example that satisfies the statement but falsifies the conclusion. If one exists, the conclusion is invalid.
Good luck with your preparation!