Delhi PSC – Reasoning Ability
Statement & Conclusion
Exam Focus – IIT‑JEE style rigor, logical depth, and exam‑specific pitfalls.
Goal – Understand the logical skeleton behind every Statement‑Conclusion problem and master the systematic deduction required to answer with confidence.
1. What is a Statement & Conclusion Question?
| Component | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Statement(s) | A set of propositions (facts, observations, or rules). |
| Conclusion(s) | A proposition that may or may not logically follow from the statements. |
| Task | Determine which conclusion(s) are necessarily true given all the statements. |
Key Idea – A conclusion is valid only if it is true in every possible scenario that satisfies all the statements.
2. Translating Natural Language to Propositional Logic
| Natural‑language pattern | Propositional Symbol | Example |
|---|---|---|
| “If … then …” | (P \rightarrow Q) | If it rains, the ground is wet. |
| “If and only if” | (P \leftrightarrow Q) | The light is on iff the switch is pressed. |
| “Either … or …” (inclusive) | (P \lor Q) | Either the door is open, or the window is open. |
| “Either … or …” (exclusive) | (P \oplus Q) | Either the door is open or the window is open, but not both. |
| “Neither … nor …” | (\neg P \land \neg Q) | Neither the door nor the window is open. |
| “Only if” | (P \rightarrow Q) (same as “if”) | The window opens only if the door is open. |
| “If …, then …, unless …” | (P \rightarrow (Q \lor \neg R)) | If it rains, then the ground is wet, unless the ground is dry. |
| “Exactly one of …” | (P \oplus Q) | Exactly one of the two lights is on. |
| “All … are …” | (\forall x (P(x) \rightarrow Q(x))) | All students are eligible. |
| “Some … are …” | (\exists x (P(x) \land Q(x))) | Some machines are defective. |
Tip – Write a truth table for each statement when the number of variables is ≤ 3. For 4+ variables, use inference rules.
3. Core Logical Inference Rules
| Rule | Symbolic Form | Quick Test | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Modus Ponens | (P \rightarrow Q,, P \vdash Q) | If P true → Q must be true. | If it rains, ground wet. It rains → Ground wet. |
| Modus Tollens | (P \rightarrow Q,, \neg Q \vdash \neg P) | If Q false → P false. | If it rains, ground wet. Ground not wet → Not raining. |
| Hypothetical Syllogism | (P \rightarrow Q,, Q \rightarrow R \vdash P \rightarrow R) | Chain of implications. | If A→B and B→C → A→C. |
| Disjunctive Syllogism | (P \lor Q,, \neg P \vdash Q) | One disjunct impossible → other true. | Either I run or I walk. I don't run → I walk. |
| Conjunction | (P,, Q \vdash P \land Q) | Both true → conjunction true. | I eat, I sleep → I eat and I sleep. |
| Simplification | (P \land Q \vdash P) | From a conjunction, take one part. | From “I eat and I sleep”, infer “I eat”. |
| Addition | (P \vdash P \lor Q) | Add a disjunct. | “I eat” → “I eat or I drink”. |
| Contraposition | (P \rightarrow Q \vdash \neg Q \rightarrow \neg P) | Flip & negate. | If it rains → ground wet. If ground not wet → not raining. |
| Reductio ad Absurdum | (\neg P \vdash) contradiction → (P) | Assume opposite, derive contradiction. | Assume “Not A” → Contradiction → “A”. |
Why These Matter – Every Statement‑Conclusion problem boils down to applying these rules to the translated logical forms.
4. Step‑by‑Step Methodology for Delhi PSC
- Read All Statements Carefully.
*