Reasoning Ability – Statement & Conclusion
“Statement & Conclusion” is a popular sub‑topic in reasoning tests such as the Mizoram Police Sub‑Inspector (SI) exam.
It evaluates your ability to derive logical conclusions from given statements while respecting constraints (order, location, etc.).
1. Simple Explanation
- Statement – A fact or condition given in the problem.
- Conclusion – A logical inference that must follow from the statement(s) under all possible configurations that satisfy the statements.
Important:
- You must be able to prove that the conclusion is true in every arrangement that satisfies the statements.
- If there exists even one arrangement that satisfies the statements but violates the conclusion, the conclusion is invalid.
2. Key Points to Remember
| # | Key Point | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Identify the type of statement – “only”, “none”, “at least”, “at most”, “exactly”, “between”, “after”, “before”, “next to”, etc. | Determines the restriction strength. |
| 2 | Check for uniqueness – If a statement says “A is the only B”, then A is the sole B. | Guarantees the conclusion. |
| 3 | Exclude impossible positions – Use “not in” or “not next to” to rule out slots. | Helps pin down the exact location. |
| 4 | Use elimination – When several items are involved, eliminate possibilities step by step. | Reduces complexity. |
| 5 | Consider all permutations – For conclusions that involve “any” or “at least”, confirm that every valid permutation satisfies it. | Avoids false conclusions. |
| 6 | Look for transitive relations – If A is before B and B is before C, then A is before C. | Enables indirect inference. |
| 7 | Beware of “only” vs “at least” – “Only” is stricter; “At least” allows more possibilities. | Determines conclusiveness. |
3. Worked Example
Problem
*Five candidates – A, B, C, D, E – are standing in a line to take a photo.
- A is standing at the leftmost position.
- B is standing exactly two places to the right of A.
- C is standing directly between B and D.
- E is standing to the right of D.
Question: Which of the following statements is a valid conclusion?
(i) C is standing to the right of B.
(ii) E is standing to the right of C.
(iii) D is standing to the left of E.
Step‑by‑Step Analysis
| Step | Reasoning | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | A is leftmost → A occupies position 1. | A = 1 |
| 2 | B is exactly two places right of A → B = 3. | B = 3 |
| 3 | C is directly between B and D → D must be at position 5 (since C is between 3 and 5). | D = 5, C = 4 |
| 4 | E is to the right of D → E must be in the only remaining slot (position 2). | E = 2 |
| 5 | Check each candidate conclusion: | |
| (i) | “C to the right of B” → 4 > 3 → True. | |
| (ii) | “E to the right of C” → 2 > 4 → False. | |
| (iii) | “D to the left of E” → 5 < 2 → False. |
Only (i) is a valid conclusion.
Conclusion: The only statement that must hold in every arrangement satisfying the given statements is (i) – “C is standing to the right of B.”
4. Quick Revision Summary
| Section | Take‑away |
|---|---|
| Statement & Conclusion | Derive mandatory inferences that hold for all permissible arrangements. |
| Identify statement type | “Only”, “at least”, “exactly”, “between”, “next to”, etc. |
| Use elimination & transitivity | Narrow down positions step by step. |
| Test all permutations | Ensure the conclusion cannot be violated by any valid arrangement. |
| Common pitfalls | Confusing “only” with “at least”, overlooking “directly between”, assuming “to the right” means “immediately right”. |
| Practice tip | Write out the linear order after each step; check for contradictions immediately. |
Final Tip for the Exam
- Always start by placing the most constrained items first (e.g., leftmost, rightmost, or “exactly X places apart”).
- Draw a quick diagram (positions 1–5) and fill in numbers.
- Cross‑check every conclusion against the diagram before marking it.
Good luck with your preparation!