Statement & Conclusion – Reasoning Ability
Mizoram Police Constable Exam – Study Notes
1. Simple Explanation
| Term | What it Means | How to Spot It |
|---|---|---|
| Statement | A fact or proposition that is necessarily true in the given context. | Usually presented as a premise or a fact that all other statements are built upon. |
| Conclusion | A logical inference drawn from one or more statements. | Must follow necessarily from the statements; cannot be assumed or guessed. |
Key Idea
- A conclusion is derived from the statements, not the other way round.
- If you can replace the conclusion with a statement and still make everything true, you’ve found a statement.
2. Key Points
| # | Concept | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Logical Flow | Statements → Conclusion. A conclusion can’t exist without its supporting statements. |
| 2 | Validity Test | If removing the conclusion still keeps the statements logically consistent, the conclusion is not mandatory. |
| 3 | Necessity vs. Sufficiency | Statements are necessary for the conclusion. The conclusion may also require additional facts (sufficiency). |
| 4 | Common Pitfalls | - Treating a conclusion as a statement (e.g., “All dogs are animals” when given “All mammals are animals” and “All dogs are mammals”). - Assuming a statement is a conclusion when it can be independently true. |
| 5 | Use of “Therefore” | The word therefore often indicates a conclusion, but it’s not a guarantee. Verify logical dependency first. |
| 6 | Multiple Statements | A conclusion may rely on all given statements together. |
| 7 | Transformation | Exchanging a conclusion for a statement is only possible if the conclusion’s truth doesn’t depend on any other facts. |
3. Worked Example
Given Statements
- All birds can fly.
- Penguins are birds.
- Penguins do not fly.
Question: Identify which of the following is a statement and which is a conclusion.
a) Penguins are birds.
b) Penguins can fly.
c) Penguins do not fly.
| Item | Is it a Statement? | Is it a Conclusion? | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| a) Penguins are birds | ✅ | ❌ | This is a fact given initially (statement). |
| b) Penguins can fly | ❌ | ❌ | It’s not given; it is contradicted by the facts. |
| c) Penguins do not fly | ❌ | ✅ | It follows from (1) & (2) that penguins should fly, but (3) states they don’t. The only way to reconcile is to conclude that the general rule (1) is not universal, i.e., “All birds can fly” is false. Thus the conclusion is that “All birds can fly” is false, which is inferred from the contradiction. |
Take‑away
- (a) is a statement.
- (c) is a conclusion derived by contradiction.
- (b) is neither (it's an impossible statement given the data).
4. Quick Revision Summary
| What to Remember | How to Use It |
|---|---|
| Statements are facts that form the foundation. | Treat them as given premises. |
| Conclusions are logical inferences built only from the statements. | Always check that the conclusion cannot stand alone. |
| Verify by removing the supposed conclusion; if the remaining statements still hold, the removed part was a statement. | Practice with sample questions. |
| Use “therefore,” “hence,” “thus” as hints but not proof. | Don’t rely solely on wording. |
| Test necessity: If the conclusion is necessary to keep statements consistent, it’s likely a conclusion. | Quick mental test before marking. |
Final Tip
When in doubt, rewrite the argument in your own words. If the sentence you’re considering can be stated independently, it’s a statement. If it only makes sense when the other facts are considered, it’s a conclusion.
Happy studying!