Syllogism – Advanced Study Notes
(For the Ladakh Police Sub‑Inspector (SI) Reasoning Ability Examination – MIT‑Level Treatment)
1. Introduction
-
Syllogism (from syllogismos “conclusion” in Greek) is a deductive argument consisting of two premises (major and minor) and a conclusion, all of which are categorical statements of the form
[ \text{All } A \text{ are } B,\quad \text{No } A \text{ are } C,\quad \text{Some } A \text{ are } B,\quad \text{Some } A \text{ are not } B ] -
It is the cornerstone of traditional (Aristotelian) logic and remains a staple in reasoning‑ability tests, especially for law‑enforcement and judiciary examinations.
-
The goal of this note is to present a rigorous, first‑principles exploration of syllogistic logic, its validity tests, edge cases, and extensions to predicate logic—all while keeping the exposition application‑centric for police reasoning.
2. Historical & Conceptual Foundations
| Era | Key Contributor | Contribution |
|---|---|---|
| 5th BC – 3rd BC | Aristotle | Formulated the five figures of syllogisms and the rules of distribution |
| 19th C | George Boole | Introduced Boolean algebra; laid groundwork for symbolic logic |
| Early 20th C | Gottlob Frege, Bertrand Russell | Developed predicate logic (first‑order logic) – extended syllogisms to quantified statements |
| Late 20th C | David Lewis, George Boolos | Formalized modal and deontic syllogisms relevant to legal reasoning |
Key Insight: Every categorical syllogism can be encoded as a predicate‑logic statement with quantifiers, but the classical form remains useful for quick mental checks in high‑pressure settings.
3. Formal Foundations
3.1 Syntax of Categorical Statements
Let (X) be a predicate (property), (x) a variable, and (\forall, \exists) the universal and existential quantifiers.
- Universal affirmative (A‑form)
[ \forall x,(P(x) \rightarrow Q(x))\quad\text{(All } P \text{ are } Q) ] - Universal negative (E‑form)
[ \forall x,(P(x) \rightarrow \lnot Q(x))\quad\text{(No } P \text{ are } Q) ] - Particular affirmative (I‑form)
[ \exists x,(P(x) \land Q(x))\quad\text{(Some } P \text{ are } Q) ] - Particular negative (O‑form)
[ \exists x,(P(x) \land \lnot Q(x))\quad\text{(Some } P \text{ are not } Q) ]
3.2 Structure of a Syllogism
| Component | Symbol | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Major Premise | (P \rightarrow Q) | All criminals are lawbreakers |
| Minor Premise | (R \rightarrow P) | All robbers are criminals |
| Conclusion | (R \rightarrow Q) | All robbers are lawbreakers |
4. Classical Analysis of Categorical Syllogisms
| Figure | Major Term | Minor Term | Middle Term | Validity Criteria |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | (A) | (B) | (M) | 1. Every (M) is (A) (major). 2. Every (B) is (M) (minor). 3. Conclusion: Every (B) is (A). |
| 2 | (A) | (M) | (B) | 1. Every (B) is (A). 2. Every (M) is (B). 3. Conclusion: Every (M) is (A). |
| 3 | (M) | (A) | (B) | 1. Every (A) is (M). 2. Every (B) is (M). 3. Conclusion: All (A) are (B)?? (invalid) |
| 4 | (M) | (B) | (A) | 1. Every (B) is (M). 2. Every (A) is (M). 3. Conclusion: All (A) are (B)? (invalid) |
Rule of Distribution
A term is distributed iff it refers to all members of its class.
- Universal affirmative (All) – distributes the subject.
- Universal negative (No) – distributes both subject and predicate.
- Particular affirmative/negative (Some) – distributes none.
4.1 Valid Forms (Aristotle’s Six Valid Syllogisms)
| Figure | Mood (P–M–C) | Validity | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | AAA | Valid |