Syllogism

Logical Reasoning · free study notes

Syllogism – Advanced Study Notes

(For the Ladakh Police Sub‑Inspector (SI) Reasoning Ability Examination – MIT‑Level Treatment)


1. Introduction

  • Syllogism (from syllogismos “conclusion” in Greek) is a deductive argument consisting of two premises (major and minor) and a conclusion, all of which are categorical statements of the form
    [ \text{All } A \text{ are } B,\quad \text{No } A \text{ are } C,\quad \text{Some } A \text{ are } B,\quad \text{Some } A \text{ are not } B ]

  • It is the cornerstone of traditional (Aristotelian) logic and remains a staple in reasoning‑ability tests, especially for law‑enforcement and judiciary examinations.

  • The goal of this note is to present a rigorous, first‑principles exploration of syllogistic logic, its validity tests, edge cases, and extensions to predicate logic—all while keeping the exposition application‑centric for police reasoning.


2. Historical & Conceptual Foundations

Era Key Contributor Contribution
5th BC – 3rd BC Aristotle Formulated the five figures of syllogisms and the rules of distribution
19th C George Boole Introduced Boolean algebra; laid groundwork for symbolic logic
Early 20th C Gottlob Frege, Bertrand Russell Developed predicate logic (first‑order logic) – extended syllogisms to quantified statements
Late 20th C David Lewis, George Boolos Formalized modal and deontic syllogisms relevant to legal reasoning

Key Insight: Every categorical syllogism can be encoded as a predicate‑logic statement with quantifiers, but the classical form remains useful for quick mental checks in high‑pressure settings.


3. Formal Foundations

3.1 Syntax of Categorical Statements

Let (X) be a predicate (property), (x) a variable, and (\forall, \exists) the universal and existential quantifiers.

  1. Universal affirmative (A‑form)
    [ \forall x,(P(x) \rightarrow Q(x))\quad\text{(All } P \text{ are } Q) ]
  2. Universal negative (E‑form)
    [ \forall x,(P(x) \rightarrow \lnot Q(x))\quad\text{(No } P \text{ are } Q) ]
  3. Particular affirmative (I‑form)
    [ \exists x,(P(x) \land Q(x))\quad\text{(Some } P \text{ are } Q) ]
  4. Particular negative (O‑form)
    [ \exists x,(P(x) \land \lnot Q(x))\quad\text{(Some } P \text{ are not } Q) ]

3.2 Structure of a Syllogism

Component Symbol Example
Major Premise (P \rightarrow Q) All criminals are lawbreakers
Minor Premise (R \rightarrow P) All robbers are criminals
Conclusion (R \rightarrow Q) All robbers are lawbreakers

4. Classical Analysis of Categorical Syllogisms

Figure Major Term Minor Term Middle Term Validity Criteria
1 (A) (B) (M) 1. Every (M) is (A) (major). 2. Every (B) is (M) (minor). 3. Conclusion: Every (B) is (A).
2 (A) (M) (B) 1. Every (B) is (A). 2. Every (M) is (B). 3. Conclusion: Every (M) is (A).
3 (M) (A) (B) 1. Every (A) is (M). 2. Every (B) is (M). 3. Conclusion: All (A) are (B)?? (invalid)
4 (M) (B) (A) 1. Every (B) is (M). 2. Every (A) is (M). 3. Conclusion: All (A) are (B)? (invalid)

Rule of Distribution
A term is distributed iff it refers to all members of its class.

  1. Universal affirmative (All) – distributes the subject.
  2. Universal negative (No) – distributes both subject and predicate.
  3. Particular affirmative/negative (Some) – distributes none.

4.1 Valid Forms (Aristotle’s Six Valid Syllogisms)

Figure Mood (P–M–C) Validity Example
1 AAA Valid

Your note

Page 1

Doubt hai is topic me?

Free AI teacher se poocho — 24/7, step by step.