Time & Work – Advanced University‑Level Study Notes
(For the Andaman & Nicobar Islands PSC – Quantitative Aptitude)
Prerequisites – Basic algebra, fractions, proportions, simple linear equations.
Goal – Master the Time‑Work framework, derive formulas from first principles, explore non‑standard scenarios, and solve a challenging problem.
1. Foundations – Work as a Quantitative Entity
1.1 Definition of Work
- Work is any task that consumes time and effort.
- Quantify work in “man‑hours” (or “person‑hours”):
[ \text{Work} = \text{Rate} \times \text{Time} ] where Rate = units of work done per hour by a person.
1.2 Rate of Work
- If a person completes (W) units of work in (T) hours, his rate (r) is: [ r = \frac{W}{T}\quad \text{(units per hour)} ]
- For a group of (n) persons working together, assuming ideal additive rates: [ R_{\text{group}} = \sum_{i=1}^{n} r_i ] (Later we will discuss non‑idealities.)
1.3 Work Done by Multiple People
-
Formula: [ \boxed{W = R_{\text{total}} \times T} ] where (R_{\text{total}}) is the combined rate.
-
Alternative viewpoint:
The total work requirement (W) is fixed for a given problem.
The time (T) is variable depending on the effective rate.
2. Core Time‑Work Relations
2.1 Single Person, Single Task
[ T = \frac{W}{r} ]
2.2 Two (or More) Persons Working Together
Let (r_1, r_2, \dots, r_n) be individual rates.
[ T = \frac{W}{\sum_{i=1}^{n} r_i} ]
2.3 Different Persons Working for Different Durations
Suppose Person A works (t_1) hours, Person B works (t_2) hours, etc.
[ W_{\text{total}} = r_1 t_1 + r_2 t_2 + \dots + r_n t_n ]
This is the additive work model.
2.4 Work Done When One Person Leaves or Arrives
If a person stops after (t_k) hours, his contribution is (r_k t_k).
The remaining persons continue at their combined rate.
3. Deriving the General Formula from First Principles
3.1 Starting Point – Differential Approach
Let (w(t)) be the cumulative work completed up to time (t).
[ \frac{dw}{dt} = R(t) ]
where (R(t)) is the instantaneous total rate (possibly time‑dependent).
Integrating:
[ w(T) = \int_0^T R(t),dt = W ]
For constant rates over intervals, this reduces to simple multiplication.
3.2 Piecewise Constant Rates
If the workforce changes at times (t_1, t_2, \dots):
[ W = \sum_{k=1}^{m} R_k \cdot (t_k - t_{k-1}) ]
with (t_0 = 0), (t_m = T).
This covers “work done by different teams at different times”.
3.3 Continuous Variations – e.g., Training or Fatigue
If rate (r(t) = r_0 (1 - \alpha t)) (linear fatigue):
[ W = \int_0^T r_0 (1 - \alpha t),dt = r_0 \left( T - \frac{\alpha}{2} T^2 \right) ]
Solving for (T) yields a quadratic; this is rarely used in PSC questions but illustrates advanced modeling.
4. Edge Cases & Common Pitfalls
| Scenario | Typical Mistake | Correct Approach |
|---|---|---|
| Two people start, one leaves early | Treat remaining person as not starting from zero. | Compute work done by first person until exit, then use remaining person’s rate for rest. |
| Work shared but rates not equal | Assume equal division of work. | Use individual rates to compute total rate. |
| Different units | Mix hours, minutes, days without conversion. | Convert all time units to a common base (e.g., hours). |
| Work “per day” vs “per hour” | Forget that “per day” implies 24 h. | Clarify working hours; e.g., if 8‑hour day, rate per day = 8 × (rate per hour). |
| Non‑linear rates | Apply constant‑rate formula. | Use integral or piecewise sums if rates change. |
| Negative rates | Occurs when a person “undoes” work. | Consider subtraction in total rate: (R_{\text{total}} = r_1 + r_2 - r_3). |
5. Advanced Topics
5.1 Parallel vs Sequential Work
- Parallel: People working simultaneously on the same task.
- Sequential: One person starts, then another takes over.
- Sequential time: (T = T_A + T_B).
- Parallel time: (T = \frac{W}{r_A + r_B}).
5.2 Machine & Human Hybrid Work
Let (m) be machine rate, (p) be human rate.
If the machine can work continuously (24 h) and human only 8 h/day, adjust rates accordingly.
5.3 Work with Partial Effort
If a person works only part of a day, use fraction of total rate:
(r_{\text{effective}} = r \times \frac{\text{working hours}}{24}).
6. Challenging Problem (Solution Included)
Problem
Three workers, A, B, and C, can complete a certain job in 8, 12, and 20 days respectively, working 8 hours each day.
- They work together for 4 days.
- After that, A leaves, and B and C continue.
- Then, after 3 more