Statement & Conclusion – Reasoning Ability
(Andaman & Nicobar Islands Police Constable – Competitive Exam)
Goal: Learn how to deduce conclusions from given statements, and how to evaluate the validity of a proposed conclusion.
Why it matters: The “Statement & Conclusion” (S&C) pattern is one of the most common, yet most confusing, reasoning sections in competitive exams such as JEE‑Mains, JEE‑Advanced, AIEEE, NTA, UPPSC, etc.
1. Conceptual Overview
| Term | Definition | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Statement (S) | A proposition or fact that is given as true. | “All roses are flowers.” |
| Conclusion (C) | A proposition that may or may not follow from the statements. | “Some flowers are roses.” |
| Assumption | Any additional statement that may be implicitly or explicitly required to deduce the conclusion. | “All roses are red.” |
| Validity | A conclusion is valid if every interpretation of the statements (and any necessary assumptions) makes the conclusion true. Otherwise it is invalid. | “All roses are flowers” ⇒ “All flowers are roses” (invalid). |
Key Idea:
A conclusion is valid only if it is necessary (must be true) given the statements (and any implicit assumptions).
2. The Standard Procedure
| Step | What to Do | Tips |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Identify the statement(s). | Write them down clearly. | Use shorthand if needed, e.g., S1: All A are B. |
| 2. Identify the conclusion(s). | Write the conclusion(s) that need to be evaluated. | e.g., C1: Some A are B. |
| 3. Classify the type of S&C. | Single/Multiple statements, Single/Multiple conclusions. | Different patterns require different techniques. |
| 4. Assume the conclusion is true. | Check if it leads to a contradiction with the statements. | If contradiction → conclusion is invalid. |
| 5. Assume the negation of the conclusion. | If this does not contradict the statements, the conclusion is invalid. | If it forces the conclusion, it's valid. |
| 6. Use logical connectors. | All, No, Some, Not, Some but not all, etc. |
Translate into set relations. |
| 7. Use a truth table or Venn diagram if the set of possibilities is small. | Verify all possible assignments. | Good for 2–3 sets. |
| 8. Check for hidden assumptions. | Are there any implicit premises? | Often the trick is to spot a missing assumption. |
| 9. Answer the question | Mark “Valid”, “Invalid”, or “Both” (if multiple conclusions). | Double-check before finalizing. |
3. Logical Relations & Shortcuts
| Relation | Symbolic Representation | Example | Shortcut |
|---|---|---|---|
| All | ( \forall x (x \in A \rightarrow x \in B) ) | “All cats are mammals.” | A ⊆ B |
| No | ( \forall x (x \in A \rightarrow x \notin B) ) | “No cats are dogs.” | A ∩ B = ∅ |
| Some | ( \exists x (x \in A \land x \in B) ) | “Some cats are black.” | A ∩ B ≠ ∅ |
| Not all | ( \exists x (x \in A \land x \notin B) ) | “Not all cats are black.” | A ⊄ B |
| Some but not all | ( \exists x (x \in A \land x \in B) \land \exists x (x \in A \land x \notin B) ) | “Some cats are black but not all.” | A ∩ B ≠ ∅ and A ⊄ B |
Important:
When dealing with “Some” statements, remember that they do not imply the absence of a universal statement. For instance, “Some cats are black” does not rule out “All cats are black.”
4. Common Pitfalls & Tricky Points
| Pitfall | What to Watch For | Correct Approach |
|---|---|---|
| Assuming “Some” implies “All” | “Some A are B” → “All A are B” (false). | Never make this jump. |
| Missing a hidden assumption | A conclusion may require an implicit premise. | If we can’t deduce it from the statements alone, mark invalid. |
| Misreading “No” statements | “No A are B” → “All A are not B” (true) but not “All B are not A”. | Keep the direction of implication. |
| Confusing “Some but not all” with “Not all” | Both need at least one element in both directions. | Check both existence and absence. |
| Using only one direction of implication | “All A are B” does not imply “All B are A”. | Explicitly check reverse. |
| Overlooking the possibility of a false conclusion |