Contracts & Torts – Study Notes
1. Simple Explanation
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Contract | A legally enforceable agreement between two or more parties that creates obligations. |
| Tort | A civil wrong (not a contract) that causes injury or loss to another person, giving the injured party a right to sue for damages. |
- Contracts arise by agreement (offer + acceptance + consideration).
- Torts arise by conduct (negligence, nuisance, defamation, etc.).
- Both have civil remedies (damages, injunction, specific performance), but they are distinct legal doctrines.
2. Key Points
| Area | Key Points |
|---|---|
| Elements of a Contract | 1. Offer 2. Acceptance (mirror image, unequivocal) 3. Consideration (something of value) 4. Intention to create legal relations 5. Capacity & legality |
| Types of Contracts | • Express vs Implied • Bilateral vs Unilateral • Void, Voidable, Unenforceable |
| Defects & Remedies | • Misrepresentation (fraudulent, negligent, innocent) – rescission or damages. • Breach – material vs minor; remedies: damages, specific performance, injunction, rescission. |
| Doctrine of Consideration | Must be real, sufficient, not past; assumption of risk can negate it. |
| Tort Elements | 1. Duty of care (negligence) 2. Breach of duty 3. Causation (actual & proximate) 4. Damages |
| Common Torts | • Negligence (most common) • Strict Liability (e.g., product liability, abnormally dangerous activities) • Intentional Torts (battery, assault, defamation, trespass, false imprisonment) • Nuisance (private & public) |
| Causation | • Actual cause (cause‑in‑fact, “but‑for” test) • Proximate cause (foreseeability) |
| Defences in Torts | • Contributory / comparative negligence • Assumption of risk • Statutory immunity |
| Damages | • Compensatory (actual, consequential) • Nominal • Punitive (in tort only) • Liquidated damages (contract) |
| Remedies Comparison | • Contract: damages, specific performance, injunction, rescission. • Tort: damages, injunction, exemplary (punitive) damages. |
3. Worked Example
Scenario
Contract:
- Parties: ABC Builders (contractor) and John (homeowner).
- Agreement: ABC Builders will complete a house renovation for ₹10,00,000, payable upon completion.
- Issue: ABC Builders fail to finish the work and leave the site in disrepair. John sues for breach.
Tort:
- Scenario: While renovating, ABC Builders mistakenly left a heavy ladder on the sidewalk, causing a pedestrian, Ramesh, to slip and break his arm. Ramesh sues ABC Builders for negligence.
Analysis
| Issue | Contract Analysis | Tort Analysis |
|---|---|---|
| Existence of Contract | Offer: ABC Builders’ quotation. Acceptance: John’s signed contract. Consideration: ₹10,00,000. Intention: Both parties intended to create legal relations. | N/A |
| Breach | Failure to complete work = material breach. | Failure to maintain safe premises = breach of duty of care. |
| Remedies | John can claim: • Damages for loss of use, cost to hire another contractor (reliability). • Rescission (cancel contract). • Injunction (prevent ABC from doing further damage). |
Ramesh can claim: • Compensatory damages (medical bills, lost wages). • Punitive damages if ABC’s conduct was reckless. |
| Causation | Breach caused loss of utility of the property. | Ladder left on sidewalk caused Ramesh’s injury – actual cause. |
| Defences | ABC could argue: • Force majeure (e.g., natural disaster). • Partial performance (some work done). |
ABC could argue: • Contributory negligence (Ramesh was walking too fast). • Assumption of risk (public walking). |
| Outcome | John likely wins damages and may recover the cost of completing the renovation. | Ramesh likely wins compensatory damages; ABC may be liable for punitive damages if gross negligence proven. |
4. Quick Revision Summary
| Topic | Key Take‑away |
|---|---|
| Contract | Must have offer, acceptance, consideration, intention, capacity. Breach → damages, specific performance, rescission. |
| Tort | Duty → breach → causation → damages. Negligence is the most common tort. |
| Remedies | Contract: damages (compensatory), specific performance, rescission, injunction. Tort: compensatory, punitive, injunction. |
| Defences | Misrepresentation, force majeure, contributory negligence, assumption of risk. |
| Causation | Actual cause = “but‑for”; Proximate cause = foreseeability. |
| Damages Types | Compensatory (actual, consequential), nominal, punitive (tort only). |
| Comparison | Contracts arise by agreement; torts by conduct. Remedies overlap but torts can award punitive damages. |
Tip: When solving a case, first determine whether it’s a contract or tort problem. Then apply the appropriate elements and remedies.
Practice Question: Draft a brief contract between a photographer and a client. Identify the five elements and explain what would happen if the photographer fails to deliver the photos.
Happy studying!