NMAT – Data Interpretation & Logical Reasoning
Topic: Puzzles
Puzzles are a type of logical reasoning question that tests your ability to deduce relationships, order, or placement from given clues. They often involve seating arrangements, sequences, timelines, or spatial layouts.
1. Simple Explanation
-
Goal: Determine the correct order, position, or arrangement that satisfies all the given clues.
-
Common Formats:
- Seating/Row puzzles – people/objects arranged in a line or circle.
- Sequence puzzles – items arranged in a particular order (time, size, etc.).
- Spatial puzzles – items placed in a grid or on a map.
- Logical deduction puzzles – use of “if‑then,” “not,” and “exactly” statements.
-
Methodology:
- List all entities (people, items, positions).
- Write each clue as a constraint (e.g., “A sits to the left of B”).
- Create a table or diagram to track possibilities.
- Apply elimination: Use constraints to rule out impossible arrangements.
- Iterate until all entities are placed uniquely.
2. Key Points
| # | Key Point | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Clue Parsing | Misreading “to the left” vs. “to the right” can reverse the entire solution. |
| 2 | Relative vs. Absolute Positioning | “Between” or “next to” is relative; “first” or “last” is absolute. |
| 3 | Transitive Relationships | If A > B and B > C, then A > C. Use this to chain clues. |
| 4 | Exclusive Conditions | “Exactly one” or “no more than one” limits possibilities drastically. |
| 5 | Cross‑Referencing | Use one clue to narrow down options for another; often a two‑step deduction. |
| 6 | Iterative Testing | If stuck, assume a position for one entity and test consistency; backtrack if contradiction. |
| 7 | Time & Space Efficiency | NMAT puzzles are timed; practice speed by memorising common patterns. |
3. Worked Example
Puzzle
In a straight row from left to right, six books (A, B, C, D, E, F) are arranged on a shelf.
Clues:
- A is to the left of C.
- E is right of B.
- D is not adjacent to A.
- C is between D and F.
- B is the third book from the left.
- F is the last book on the right.
Solution Steps
| Step | Action | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Place B at position 3 (clue 5). | Absolute position. |
| 2 | Place F at position 6 (clue 6). | Absolute position. |
| 3 | Since C is between D and F, C cannot be at position 6. | D and F must flank C. |
| 4 | E is right of B → E must be at position 4, 5, or 6. 6 occupied by F, so E at 4 or 5. | |
| 5 | A is left of C → A must be at position 1 or 2 (since B at 3). | |
| 6 | D is not adjacent to A → If A at 1, D cannot be at 2. If A at 2, D cannot be at 1 or 3. | |
| 7 | Try A at 1: | |
| • D cannot be 2 → D at 3? No (B). 4? Possible. 5? Possible. | ||
| • C must be between D and F. | F at 6, so C at 4 or 5 if D at 3 or 4. | |
| • E at 4 or 5; but if C at 5, E cannot be 5. | Thus C at 4, D at 5, E at 5 impossible. | |
| • Contradiction – A cannot be 1. | ||
| 8 | Place A at 2. | |
| • D cannot be 1 or 3. So D at 4 or 5. | ||
| • C between D and F → D must be at 4, C at 5. | ||
| • E right of B → E at 5 or 6. 6 is F, so E at 5? But C occupies 5. Contradiction. | ||
| • Wait: D at 5, C at 4? Then C between D (5) and F (6) – yes. | ||
| • E must be right of B → E at 4 or 5? 4 is C, 5 is D. Contradiction. | ||
| Reset: Try A at 2, D at 4, C at 5, E at 4? No. | ||
| Better: A at 2, D at 4, C at 5, E at 4? Not possible. | ||
| Re‑evaluate: Maybe A at 2, D at 5, C at 4? | D at 5, C at 4, F at 6 → C between D & F satisfied. | |
| • E right of B → E at 5 or 6; 5 is D, 6 is F → impossible. | ||
| Conclusion: No arrangement works with A at 2? | ||
| 9 | Re‑check assumption: B may not be fixed at 3? But clue 5 says third from left → fixed. | |
| 10 | Re‑examine step 4: E could be at 5 (since 4 possible but 5 also). | |
| 11 | Try A at 1 again but with different placement: | |
| • B at 3, A at 1. | ||
| • D cannot be 2 (adjacent). So D at 4 or 5. | ||
| • If D at 4, C must be between D and F → C at 5. | ||
| • E right of B → E at 4 or 5. 4 is D, 5 is C → E cannot. Contradiction. | ||
| • If D at 5, C |