Statement & Conclusion – Reasoning Ability
1. What is a Statement & Conclusion Question?
- Statement – A fact or observation that is certainly true (usually stated in the present tense).
- Conclusion – A logical inference that follows from all given statements (but may not be a direct fact).
Key rule – The conclusion must be true in every possible scenario that satisfies the statements.
2. How to Approach
| Step | What to Do | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Identify the Statements | List each statement clearly. | Sets the base facts. |
| 2. Look for Implications | Translate statements into conditional or relational forms (A → B, A & B = C). | Helps see indirect links. |
| 3. Enumerate All Possibilities | Consider every logical arrangement consistent with all statements. | Needed to check “in all cases” condition. |
| 4. Test Conclusions | Verify if the conclusion holds in every arrangement. | Confirms validity. |
| 5. Select the Correct Answer | Choose the conclusion that satisfies the test. | Final answer. |
3. Quick Algorithm (Flow)
For each answer choice:
1. Assume the choice is true.
2. Check if any statement contradicts it.
3. If no contradictions, try to construct a counter‑example.
4. If counter‑example exists → choice is **not** a valid conclusion.
5. If no counter‑example → choice is a valid conclusion.
4. Worked Example
Statement 1: If the train is delayed, then the bus will also be delayed.
Statement 2: The bus was delayed.
Conclusion: The train was delayed.
1. Translate
| Statement | Logical Form |
|---|---|
| S1 | Delay(train) → Delay(bus) |
| S2 | Delay(bus) |
2. Analyze
From S2 we know the bus is delayed.
S1 tells us: If the train is delayed, then the bus is delayed.
But the converse isn’t guaranteed: bus delay does not imply train delay.
3. Counter‑example
- Train on time, bus delayed → satisfies both statements but violates the conclusion.
4. Verdict
Conclusion is not a valid inference.
5. Common Pitfalls
| Mistake | Why it’s wrong |
|---|---|
| Assuming “if A then B” → “if B then A” | Logical fallacy (converse error). |
| Ignoring “all possible cases” | Many questions allow alternative scenarios. |
| Mixing up possibility with certainty | Conclusion must be certainly true, not just possible. |
6. Quick Revision Summary
- Statement = fact, Conclusion = universal inference.
- Rule: Conclusion must hold in every scenario that satisfies all statements.
- Method:
- List statements.
- Translate to logic.
- Enumerate possibilities.
- Test each answer.
- Converse error – don’t assume “if B then A”.
- Check – try to build a counter‑example; if you can, the conclusion is wrong.
Tip: Practice with simple “if‑then” chains; as you become comfortable spotting logical dependencies, the process becomes almost automatic. Happy studying!