Seating Arrangement – Reasoning Ability
(District Judge Exam – Reasoning Ability Section)
1. Simple Explanation
A seating arrangement problem asks you to deduce the positions of people (or objects) in a row, circle, or grid based on a set of clues.
- Each clue gives a relationship (who sits next to whom, who is to the left/right, etc.).
- You must satisfy all clues simultaneously.
- Logical deduction, elimination, and sometimes trial‑and‑error are used.
2. Key Points to Remember
| # | Concept | How to Apply |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Direction Basics | Left/Right – relative to the viewer, Left of – person sits to the left side of the mentioned person. |
| 2 | Adjacency | Next to, immediately to the left/right, separated by one person etc. |
| 3 | Relative Positioning | Between, besides, on the far left/right, at the end |
| 4 | Multiple Constraints | Write each clue separately; mark what is fixed, what is variable. |
| 5 | Use a Grid / Table | Columns = seats, rows = people; cross‑mark impossible spots. |
| 6 | Elimination | If A cannot be in seat 1, mark seat 1 as X for A. |
| 7 | Trial & Error | When stuck, make an assumption, propagate it, and see if a contradiction arises. |
| 8 | Check All Clues | After filling, re‑read every clue to confirm no violation. |
3. Worked Example
Problem
Seven people (A, B, C, D, E, F, G) are to sit in a row of seven seats (1 to 7). The following conditions apply:
- A sits to the left of B.
- C sits immediately to the right of E.
- D sits somewhere between B and G.
- F sits in seat 4.
- G sits at one end of the row.
- E sits at seat 2.
Question: Who sits at seat 7?
Step‑by‑Step
| Step | Action | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Place fixed data: F at seat 4, E at seat 2, G at an end (seat 1 or 7). | • seat 2 = E • seat 4 = F • seat 1 or 7 = G |
| 2 | From clue 2: C is immediately right of E → C at seat 3. | seat 3 = C |
| 3 | Clue 1: A left of B. | A somewhere left of B |
| 4 | Clue 3: D between B and G. | D must be seated between B and G. |
| 5 | Since G is at an end, examine two cases. |
Case 1: G at seat 1
- Seats left of G: none → D cannot be between B and G → impossible.
- Reject Case 1.
Case 2: G at seat 7
- Remaining seats: 5, 6 for A, B, D (since seat 4 is F, seat 5, 6 unknown).
- D must be between B and G → D can be seat 5 or 6 (since G is seat 7).
- A left of B → B cannot be seat 5 (would put A to left but seat 5 left positions: 5 & 6 only).
- Try B at seat 6 → A at seat 5, D at seat 5? impossible.
- Therefore B at seat 5, A at seat ? left of 5 → seat ? not possible (only seat 1‑4 are left but occupied).
- So D must be seat 5, B seat 6, A seat ? left of B → seat ? = seat ? none.
Wait: We mis‑assigned. Let's re‑approach:
- Seats remaining: 5, 6.
- D between B and G → with G at 7, D must be seat 6 (between B at 5 and G at 7).
- Thus B at seat 5, D at seat 6.
- A left of B → A must be at seat ? left of 5 → seats 1‑4 but all occupied. Contradiction.
So we need to reconsider: maybe seat 4 (F) counts as between; D could be seat 4? But seat 4 is F.
Thus we must have mis‑interpreted “between” meaning immediately between? Usually “somewhere between” means there is at least one seat between them, not necessarily adjacent.
Re‑evaluate: D between B and G → B and G could be seats 5 and 7 with D at seat 6. Works. A left of B → A at seat ? left of 5 → seats 1‑4 but all occupied: 1=G,2=E,3=C,4=F. So no place for A → impossible.
Hence no solution? That indicates we mis‑read something. Let’s re‑check clues:
Clue 3 says D sits somewhere between B and G, meaning B and G are on opposite sides of D (not necessarily adjacent).
Thus we can set: seat 1=G, seat 7=?? Wait we rejected G at 1 earlier because D must be between B & G; if G at 1, B could be at 7 and D at 4? Yes! Let's try that:
Re‑try Case 1 (G seat 1)
- G at seat 1.
- D between B and G → B must be to the right of D, with G on left.
- F at 4, E at 2, C at 3.
- Seats left: 5, 6, 7 for A, B, D.
- D must be somewhere between B and G: G at 1, B somewhere to right of D.
- Place D at seat 5, B at seat 7 → D between G(1) and B(7) ✔.
- A left of B → A must be seat 6 (only left seat). ✔
All clues satisfied!
Thus final arrangement:
| Seat | Person |
|---|---|
| 1 | G |
| 2 | E |
| 3 | C |
| 4 | F |