Time & Work – Advanced Study Notes
(A “Navy‑AA” level treatment – MIT‑style, from first principles to edge‑case theory)
1. Introduction
Time & work problems are classic in quantitative aptitude, but they also illustrate fundamental ideas in rate problems, linear algebra, and differential equations.
In this note we:
- Build the theory from scratch.
- Derive the principal equations rigorously.
- Explore generalisations (variable rates, fractional work, negative work).
- Discuss edge cases and “impossible” scenarios.
- Present a challenging optimization problem.
All notation is standard:
- (W) = total amount of work (units).
- (r) = rate of work of a worker (units per hour).
- (t) = time (hours).
2. First Principles
2.1 Definition of Work Rate
If a worker completes (x) units of work in (y) hours, the rate is
[ r = \frac{x}{y}\quad(\text{units/hour}) ]
This is a direct ratio of work to time.
Proof of Additivity
Let workers A and B have rates (r_A) and (r_B).
If they work together for (t) hours, each contributes (r_A t) and (r_B t) units respectively.
Total work:
[ W_{\text{total}} = (r_A + r_B) t ]
Hence the combined rate is the sum of individual rates.
Assumption: The work performed by each worker is independent (no interference or synergy).
2.2 Work–Time Relation
From definition:
[ W = r,t ]
Rearranging yields the classic formulas:
- Work: (W = r t)
- Time: (t = \frac{W}{r})
- Rate: (r = \frac{W}{t})
These formulas are identities derived directly from the definition.
3. Rigorous Derivation of the “Work‑Rate” Equation
Let us formalise the derivation using integral calculus, which is useful when rates vary with time.
3.1 Constant Rate (Classical Case)
If a worker’s rate (r) is constant over ([0,,t]):
[ W = \int_{0}^{t} r,dt = r t ]
This integral is linear, confirming (W = r t).
3.2 Variable Rate
Suppose the rate is a function (r(t)). Then
[ W = \int_{0}^{t} r(s),ds ]
If (r(t)) is piecewise constant (e.g., a worker works with different speeds on different intervals), the integral reduces to a sum of products:
[ W = \sum_{i=1}^{n} r_i \Delta t_i ]
This is the general work–time relation and will be used in the edge‑case discussion.
4. General Theory
4.1 Linear System Formulation
Consider (n) workers with rates (r_1,\dots,r_n).
Let (t) be the time they all work together.
Total work:
[ W = \left(\sum_{i=1}^{n} r_i\right)t \quad \Longrightarrow \quad t = \frac{W}{\sum r_i} ]
In matrix form:
[ \mathbf{r}^\top \mathbf{t} = W ]
where (\mathbf{r}) is a row vector of rates and (\mathbf{t}) a column vector of times.
If each worker works a different duration, the system becomes:
[ \mathbf{r}^\top \mathbf{t} = W, \quad \text{with } \mathbf{t}\in \mathbb{R}^n ]
Solving for (\mathbf{t}) requires the rates to be linearly independent of the constraints.
4.2 Optimization under Constraints
Often we are asked to minimise or maximise the time (t) subject to constraints like:
- Workers are paired (two at a time).
- Some workers cannot work simultaneously (e.g., due to equipment).
- Each worker must finish a fixed fraction of the job.
This becomes a linear programming problem:
[ \begin{aligned} \min_{\mathbf{t}\ge 0} \quad & \max_i t_i \ \text{s.t.} \quad & \sum_{i} r_i t_i = W \ & \text{(additional linear constraints)} \end{aligned} ]
5. Edge Cases & Deeper Theory
| Edge Case | What Happens? | Why? |
|---|---|---|
| Zero Workers | (t \to \infty) | Sum of rates (=0) → no progress. |
| Zero Time | (W=0) | No time → no work. |
| Negative Rate | Negative work (e.g., undoing work). | Rate can be negative if a worker removes work. |
| Infinite Rate | (t\to 0) | The job is done instantaneously. |
| Non‑Additive Rates |