CA Final /Economics & Finance

Capital budgeting

Financial Management · free study notes

Capital Budgeting

Course: CA Final – Economics & Finance
Level: Advanced (MIT‑style, first principles + rigorous reasoning)
Format: Markdown – clear headings, equations, diagrams (ASCII), edge‑case discussion, and a challenging problem set.


1. Introduction

Concept Definition Why it matters
Capital budgeting The process of evaluating long‑term investment projects to decide which to undertake Determines how firms allocate scarce resources to maximise shareholder wealth
Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Present‑value analysis of future cash inflows/outflows Captures time‑value of money, risk, and opportunity cost
Net Present Value (NPV) Sum of discounted cash flows minus initial investment Positive NPV ⇒ wealth creation
Internal Rate of Return (IRR) Discount rate that zeroes NPV Gauge of project profitability
Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) Cost of equity + cost of debt weighted by capital structure Benchmark discount rate for evaluating projects

2. First Principles: Time‑Value of Money

2.1 Present‑Value Formula

[ PV = \frac{CF}{(1+r)^t} ]

  • (CF) – cash flow in period (t)
  • (r) – discount rate (risk‑adjusted)
  • (t) – time period (years)

2.2 Derivation from Continuous Compounding

[ PV = CF , e^{-\delta t}\quad\text{with}\quad \delta = \ln(1+r) ]

For small (r), (e^{-\delta t}\approx(1+r)^{-t}).

Key Insight: The discount rate (r) encapsulates opportunity cost, risk premium, and inflation.


3. Capital Budgeting Decision Rules

Rule Formula Interpretation
NPV Rule (\displaystyle NPV=\sum_{t=0}^{T}\frac{CF_t}{(1+r)^t}) Accept if (NPV>0)
IRR Rule (\displaystyle \sum_{t=0}^{T}\frac{CF_t}{(1+IRR)^t}=0) Accept if (IRR>WACC)
Profitability Index (PI) (\displaystyle PI=\frac{\sum_{t=1}^{T}\frac{CF_t}{(1+r)^t}}{-CF_0}) Accept if (PI>1)
Pay‑back Time to recover (CF_0) Quick, ignores time value of money

3.1 Edge Cases

  1. Non‑normal cash flows (multiple sign changes)
    • IRR may have multiple solutions → use NPV or PI instead.
  2. Zero or negative NPV
    • Even if IRR > WACC, if NPV ≈ 0, project may be risk‑neutral.
  3. Capital rationing
    • When funds are limited, rank projects by PI or NPV per dollar invested.

4. Detailed Analysis of NPV

4.1 Formula Expansion

[ NPV = -I_0 + \sum_{t=1}^{T}\frac{R_t - C_t}{(1+WACC)^t} ]

  • (I_0) – initial capital outlay
  • (R_t) – revenue in year (t)
  • (C_t) – operating cost in year (t)

4.2 Sensitivity Analysis

Variable NPV Impact Strategy
WACC ↑ WACC ↓ NPV Re‑evaluate cost of capital.
Growth rate of cash flows ↑ Growth ↑ NPV Forecast more accurately.
Discount period Longer horizon → more discounting Consider project lifespan.
  • Monte Carlo simulation can model uncertainty in each parameter and produce a probability distribution of NPV.

4.3 Risk‑Adjusted Discount Rate

[ r = r_f + \beta (r_m - r_f) + \gamma ]

  • (r_f) – risk‑free rate
  • (r_m) – market return
  • (\beta) – systematic risk
  • (\gamma) – project‑specific risk premium

5. IRR and its Limitations

5.1 Calculation

  • Solve (NPV(r)=0) using iterative methods (Newton‑Raphson, bisection).

5.2 Edge Cases

Problem Explanation Remedy
Multiple IRRs Cash flows change sign more than once Use NPV or PI
Negative Initial Cash Flow Projects with outflows after the first period Adjust interpretation
High discount rate IRR may be misleading if WACC is high Compare IRR to WACC

6. Advanced Topics

6.1 Capital Rationing and Portfolio Selection

  • Greedy Algorithm: Rank projects by PI & accept until budget exhausted.
  • Knapsack Problem: Use dynamic programming for optimal subset selection.

6.2 Real Options Analysis

  • Value of managerial flexibility (e.g., expand, abandon) can be added to NPV.
  • Binomial lattice or Black‑Scholes models estimate option value.

6.3 Integrated Cost of Capital

  • Dynamic WACC: Adjust for leverage changes post‑investment.
  • Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM): (r_e = r_f + \beta (r_m - r_f)).
  • After‑tax cost of debt: (r_d(1-T_c)).

7. Edge‑Case Deep Dive: Tornado Diagram & Scenario Analysis

  1. Create a Tornado Diagram to visualise which variables most affect NPV.
  2. Scenario Analysis: Build best‑case, base‑case, worst‑case cash flow trees.
  3. Probabilistic Forecast: Use Bayesian updating to refine parameters as data arrives.

8. Challenging Problem

Project A vs Project B Decision under Capital Rationing
A firm has a capital budget of ₹10 Cr. Two mutually exclusive projects are proposed:

  • Project A: Initial outlay ₹7 Cr. Cash flows for 5 years: ₹2 Cr, ₹3 Cr, ₹3 Cr, ₹2 Cr, ₹1 Cr.
  • Project B: Initial outlay **₹

Your note

Page 1

Doubt hai is topic me?

Free AI teacher se poocho — 24/7, step by step.